Where a domain specific quantum feature map pays: a cross-domain
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24425/ijet.2026.6340Abstract
Claims about quantum machine learning are routinely established on a single dataset and generalised informally. This paper tests one such claim directly. Earlier work in this series found, under a leakage-controlled predeclared protocol, that a financial-transaction-specific quantum feature map does not outperform matched classical baselines on the Kaggle Credit-Card Fraud dataset. We freeze source-column contracts and an experimental protocol in advance, inherit every predicted direction from that published result, and replicate on CICIDS-2017 (2.8 million flows) and UNSW-NB15 (257,673 records) — six paired comparisons under one Holm–Bonferroni correction. The replication is partial, and the failure is informative. The map’s advantage over naive amplitude encoding replicates on both datasets and is now established across three datasets and two domains. But the prediction that a matched RBF-SVM would win is significantly reversed on UNSW-NB15, where the quantum kernel wins by a median 0.021 F1 — identifying a regime in which the approach pays. That result is bounded: a random forest on identical cohorts outperforms the quantum kernel on both datasets, so no general claim of quantum advantage is supportable. Two further findings weaken the premise of domain-specific encoding itself. The advantage over generic quantum encodings differs in sign between the two network datasets, and the unanimous entanglement strength selected on financial data does not reproduce on either. We conclude that quantum kernel results reported on one dataset should not be assumed to transfer, in either direction, and that predeclared cross-domain replication is cheap enough to be routine. Balanced-cohort metrics are benchmark values, not deployment-prevalence estimates.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 International Journal of Electronics and Telecommunications

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.